Thursday, January 31, 2013

Of glitter and broken hearts- the evolution of our rating system


Once upon a time, a girl journeyed to a far away land in search of the nectar of the gods...
No seriously, I went to Denver for a massive wine tasting and case lot sale held by The Vineyard. My sister and her husband are oenophiles and we were excited to make an afternoon of it. We each got a hold of the brochure ahead of time (over 100 wines!) and made note of the ones we wanted to try. The event was amazing and while my brother-in-law scored his wines using the popular 50-100 scale, I believe my sister used a more straightforward 0-50 scale. Of course, my rating system was much more scientific... it was either a smiley face or a frowning face. And if I really liked it, I put a star next to it. I mean really- you just can't be too exacting about these things.

Tasting our way up the Door Peninsula
Fast forward to Wine Club 25 and tasting our way up the Door County Wine Trail. As Andrea, Christine and I were scribbling notes on our wine lists, I shared my simple-but-effective rating system with them. Of course they got a good chuckle out of it and it was implemented immediately, at first as a joke but then in earnest. And it simply wouldn't do to have just three ratings... there was definitely room for improvement! There was one wine we were particularly disappointed with: von Stiehl's Apple Icing was described as a "perfectly balanced ice wine that pairs concentrated aromas of freshly picked apples with flavors of butterscotch, vanilla and honey." Sounds intriguing, don't you think? Well, that one scored an angry face, tears, and a broken heart; Simon Creek Vineyard got several half-smiles penciled in the margin; finally finding Red Oak Vineyard was well worth it (multiple smiley face-plus-star ratings) and Door Peninsula Winery... well, we couldn't run out of there fast enough. In fact, Christine ran so fast that we lost her in the parking lot.

And to be fair, our rating system wasn't heavily tipped to one side or the other. Andrea is definitely the artist of our group and while she actually found a way to draw evil glitter, when she was happy with a wine, you knew it. All you had to do was take a look at her page- there were dancing unicorns, hearts and stars. Everything a good wine deserves.

Ah yes... but that was three months ago and we've grown up since then. We currently use a 20-point rating system which assigns a certain number of points amongst eleven different categories: color, aroma, bouquet, body, tannins, acid, sugar, balance, finish, appeal and overall opinion. Total up all the points and the wine will earn one of seven ratings: poor, fair, average, good, very good, exceptional or superior. And yes... sometimes we are torn so you may see a half point every now and then!

Monday, January 28, 2013

Wine Club 34: Battle Chardonnay and bonus books

Date: January 26th, 2013
Host: Kim
Served: Charcuterie Cones, Chicken Florentine Artichoke Bake
Bonus bottles (from the Host's personal inventory): Three Lakes Winery Old Glory, Simon Creek Chocolate Port
Bonus books: some miscellaneous cookbooks free from Christine's work, including a food-and-wine pairing course that inspired today's selections

Leese-Fitch Chardonnay
Leese-Fitch Chardonnay 2011 (Napa, CA, USA), 13.5% alcohol, $10 at Metro Market

Kim says (15): I'm not sure if a wine can smell smooth but this one did! Smooth, sweet and floral, like apple blossoms. I was pleasantly surprised by the taste of tart green apples.

Andrea says (15): This Chardonnay was a pale golden color with clear edges. I loved the bouquet - pear, honey, apricot, peach and a little floral. The taste was drier than the smell had suggested, I thought it would be sweeter. But I thought it went well with Kim's pasta and tasted of honey and apple.

Christine says (14.5): I was excited to try this wine, since we had all liked the Leese-Fitch Cabernet when we met the first time, nearly a year ago. I smelled peaches and honey in a nice bouquet. The wine was surprisingly dry and tasted of apples. I thought it was a bit oaky and could've had a bit more finesse. It was good, though, and on the dry side, as the guy who helped me at the store had promised.


Beaulieu Vineyard Chardonnay
Beaulieu Vineyard Chardonnay 2008 (Carneros, Napa Valley, CA, USA), 14.5% alcohol, $21 at Metro Market

Kim says (12.5): A deep, vibrant gold, this Chardonnay smelled like... well, alcohol. And hiding beneath that was the faint smell of peaches. I feel that 12.5 isn't a fair score (I liked it much better than that) but that's the way the points fell... color, bouquet, sugar and finish were all missed opportunities. But the really exciting thing is that thanks to this wine, a mystery has been solved! When tasting a wine (until now, it has always been a red), I have occasionally come across something that smells almost like black pepper but not quite. Something earthy, aggressive and masculine; not hot spicy but spice spicy. As I struggled to describe it, Andrea came up with a perfect word for it- something with bite. After scoring this wine, we read the label and found a likely suspect listed in the description. Just to make sure, we grabbed it off of my spice rack, crushed the grounds to release the smell and stuck our nose in it. Sure enough: nutmeg!

Andrea says (15.5): I think that the best word to describe this wine was "smooth." The color was a rich, deep gold. The first thing I smelled was also alcohol and the peppery bite that Kim described. Eventually I could make out a sweeter, tropical smell, maybe mango, apricot or pineapple? The mouth feel was rich smooth and mild. I could taste honey and vanilla but very subtle, no distinct flavors to jump out at you. I think this wine would go great with most meals, very complimentary.

Christine says (16): Most striking thing about the wine was its very intense and  deep gold color. I could only detect alcohol in the bouquet. And though the wine smelled and tasted good, it was hard to identify any one thing (slight taste of honey and pear). This was a bit more $$ than we usually have, and I do think the wine tasted expensive (at least in relative terms). But I'd contribute that to its rich, full mouthfeel rather than typical characteristics like aroma and flavor profile. I preferred it over the Leese-Fitch Chardonnay with both the yummy Soppressata appetizers (stuffed with radicchio and pepperoncini...bold flavors) and the creamy chicken pasta. Our nutmeg experiment was interesting...subtle, but definitely there.

Simon Creek Chocolate Port and a chilled glass of Old Glory
Simon Creek Chocolate Port (Madera, CA, USA), 19% alcohol, $16/500mL at Simon Creek Winery

Kim says (17): I came across this wine at a tasting and liked it enough to buy it but I had forgotten how gosh darn good it is! Given its high alcohol content, I was surprised that all I could smell was chocolate. Not sickly-sweet... a port with a nice long finish and exceptional appeal. Limited application yes, but excellent for what it's supposed to be!

Andrea says (17): Kim was nice enough to let us indulge her chocolate port, and I am a sucker for the sweet stuff. It was thick and dark purple. Completely opaque in the center with fushia edges. I could smell chocolate, alcohol and Tootsie Roll. The taste was delicious - strawberry, raspberry, chocolate, vanilla and a cream soda/root beer flavor. I was a fan!

Christine says (17): Velvety brown; rich chocolatey smell; aroma of Tootsie Pops and definitely cream soda, a scent that Andrea keyed in on. What else can I say? I like all those things, so found this port super-yummy. I'd have this for dessert all by itself (in fact, that's just what we did!).


Chicken Florentine Artichoke Bake, serves 6-8
8 oz bow tie pasta
1 small onion
1 T butter
2 eggs
1 1/4 C milk
1 t dried Italian seasoning
1/2 t salt
1/4 t crushed red pepper (optional)
2 C cooked, chopped chicken
2 C shredded Monterey Jack cheese (8oz)
1 14-oz can artichoke hearts, drained and quartered
1 10-oz package frozen chopped spinach, thawed and drained
1/2 C grated Parmesan cheese, divided

1/2 C bread crumbs
1/2 t paprika
1 T butter, melted

1. Cook pasta, drain.
2. Cook onion in 1 T butter over medium heat about 5 min or until tender. Remove from heat, set aside.
3. In a large bowl, whisk together eggs, milk, seasoning, salt, crushed red pepper.
4. Stir in the chicken, shredded cheese, artichokes, spinach, tomatoes, half the Parmesan, cooked pasta and onion.
5. Transfer to a 3-qt rectangular baking dish and bake covered for 20min at 350°.
6. In a small bowl, combine remaining Parmesan, bread crumbs, paprika and melted butter. Sprinkle over pasta.
7. Bake uncovered 10 more minutes or until golden.

Sunday, January 27, 2013

Wine Club 28: Lo Duca Mamertino, Schlink Haus Riesling

Date: November 16th, 2012
Host: Kim
Bonus bottle: Von Stiehl Kirsch




Wine Club 26 (hitting the Door County Wine Trail): Von Stiehl Dry Cherry, Red Oak Meritage II

Date: October 20th, 2012
Host: Andrea
Bonus bottle: Croft Ruby Port.












Wine Club 25: Torres Malena Garnacha, Grandmaster Meritage

Date: October 3rd, 2012
Host: Kim



Wine Club 22: Pewsey Vale Riesling, Banyan Gewürztraminer

Date: September 13th, 2012
Host: Kim
Bonus bottle: New Age Rosee.


Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Wine Club 33: Wisconsin Wine, Winter Squash Lasagna


Date: January 18th, 2013
Host: Christine

Served: Chop block bread, Butternut Squash Lasagna, Dijon-Walnut Spinach Salad, blondies
Bonus bottle (from the host's personal inventory): 2011 Rosemount Traminer Riesling

Domaine de la Terrière Beaujolais; Wollersheim Prairie Fumé
Wollersheim Prairie Fumé 2011 (Prairie du Sac, WI, USA), seyval blanc grape. 10% alcohol, $9.00

Christine says (16.5): Very pale, with slate edges. Pears, grassiness, lime and green apple in the bouquet. Taste was surprisingly honeyed, with a rich mouthfeel. This would be great with a variety of foods! Andrea said this is Wollersheim's most popular wine, and I can see why. 

Kim says (16): an odd, pale silver color... almost clear. While my olfactory perception is not half as discerning as Christine or Andrea’s, I could smell pear, grass, honey and lemon (usually I am the one that just smells “dirt” or “fruit”). Based on just the taste, I would say this wine has good appeal and paired well with the bread.

Andrea says (18.5): I really enjoyed this wine! The bouquet was awesome, and it really tasted like it smelled. Tart at first, like lime and green apple but also like honey, pear, and apricot. Great with the bread!

Domaine de la Terrière Beaujolais 2011 (France). 12% alcohol, $12.00

Christine says (15.5): Hmmm. This wine really had me stumped from the outset. It smelled like vanilla and pop tarts to me (sweet and toasty, with sugar icing). Maybe like a glazed doughnut, too. It tasted like red berries and cherries, and had a long, lingering finish. Did I also taste woodsy/wet leaves/smokiness? Yes, but I'm not sure which one. This was not your typical Beaujolais. Too many surprises! Also check out how translucent this wine was...it almost looked like colored water!

Kim says (11.5): my own score surprises me because I have a bit of a soft spot for Beaujolais. It was the first varietal that I came across that I consistently liked... steady and dependable. As Christine says, Beaujolais is a good “gateway” wine! While this particular Beaujolais scored well in the categories of tannin, acid, finish and body (interesting, given its extreme translucence), I thought it came up short in aroma and appeal. And I smelled something I never detected in a wine before... while I like the smell of a campfire, this just made me think of wet ash in the fire pit after it had been pouring rain all night. That being said, funny thing is throughout our entire meal, my glass of Beaujolais is the one I kept reaching for as it paired extremely well with Christine's amazing lasagna!

Andrea says (13): I was surprised by my score as well, I'm usually a fan of Beaujolais. The color was nice but surprisingly transparent for Beaujolais. For me, the down side was the aroma, which is how I best experience wine. All I could seem to smell was alcohol, dirt, and some how fish? The taste was nice, raspberry, cherry, and smokey. I thought it went best with the salad which had cranberry and toasted pecans, yum! I gave it a good score, but not my usually great score.

My riff on the lasagna from Vegetarian Times was a success! I decreased the squash, used cooked lasagna noodles, and added mozzarella, eggs and herbs.


1 medium butternut squash (3 pounds)
8  lasagna noodles
2 eggs
15 oz. part-skim ricotta cheese
1/2 cup grated Parmesan cheese
1-1/2 tsp. salt
1/2 tsp. ground black pepper
1/2 tsp. dried rubbed sage
1/4 tsp. each dried basil and chervil
1 cup shredded mozzarella cheese



1. Cut squash in half, seed, prick skin with a knife and roast at 350 in 1/4 inch of water for 1 hour or until tender. Cool.
2. Boil lasagna noodles and drain.
3. Combine 1 egg, ricotta, 1/4 cup Parmesan, 1/2 tsp. salt and 1/4 tsp. pepper in a bowl.
4. Scoop squash pulp into a second bowl and beat until smooth. Add 1 egg, 1 tsp. salt, 1/4 tsp. pepper and the herbs; mix well.
5. Spread 1/2 cup squash mixture into a 9-inch square baking pan coated with cooking spray. Top with two noodles (having cut one noodle in half to make a single layer three noodles wide). Top with half of the remaining squash mixture.
6. Layer with two more noodles, half of the ricotta mixture, 1/2 cup mozzarella, two noodles, remaining squash, remaining noodles and remaining cheeses (ricotta, Parmesan and mozzarella).
7. Cover and bake at 375° for 30 minutes. Uncover and bake 35-40 minutes longer or until golden brown. Let stand for 10 minutes before cutting.
                                                                  
Awww...Valentine blondies
Sun-dried tomato chop block bread
Pretty keeps us all in check!

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Wine Club 17: French Whites for a Hot Day

Date: July 19th, 2012
Host: Andrea
Served: Mom's "Legendary Mandarin Salad" and Grandma's "Dump Cake"
Bonus bottle (from the Host's personal inventory): Cupcake Red Velvet

E. Guigal Côtes du Rhône 2010 (France), 13.5% alcohol, $13
Olivier Tricon Petit Chablis NV (France), 12.5% alcohol, $12

Oliver Tricon Petit Chablis; E. Guigal Côtes du Rhône
Andrea says:
This was a meal that was a surprising success! I tweaked my mom's "Legendary Mandarin Salad" recipe. Simple yet satisfying. The wines went fine with the meal, and I gave both good scores. 17 out of 20 for the Petit Chablis ( in spite of describing the aroma as feet, burnt hair, chemicals and cat pee) and 18 out of 20 for the Cotes du Rhone (floral, grapefruit, pear, banana).

Kim says (after she stops laughing her head off):
Andrea is so nice... she always feels sorry for the wines when they behave badly! I gave the Petit Chablis a score of 13 and thought it smelled like basement. The Côtes du Rhône had an aroma of lilies and tropical flowers and while I scored it an exceptional 19, it seemed it would have a very limited application. Not a very versatile wine.

Christine says:
I gave the Cotes du Rhone  a 15 out of 20, though I thought it was a bit too assertive for many foods. I speculated whether it would team up well with a Reuben. The Petit Chablis smelled of cat pee and grass, but tasted  much better with green apple and slate flavors. Though I only gave it a 14, it was great with the Mandarin Salad!

Cupcake Red Velvet
Andrea says:
I really enjoyed the Cupcake Red Velvet and gave it an 18 out of 20. I described it with the words raspberry, cherry, chocolate, and mocha. This went well with the dump cake and would probably go well with most desserts. This is a good wine for people who are new to wine or don't think that they like red wines. It was fruity and not too bold.

Kim says:
Not being a huge fan of sweet, I enjoyed this wine which tasted vaguely like unsweetened bakers chocolate and paired well with the Dump Cake. I felt it was lacking on the finish (short) but had good appeal and nice aroma. A pretty average alcohol content of 13.5%. I scored this Cupcake at 15 points.

Christine says: 
The Cupcake Red Velvet was off the hook...red fruit, chocolate, blackberries,and a super price of $9 or $10. I gave it an 18.
Legendary Mandarin Salad
Salad:
1/2c. Sliced Almonds                          1c. Chopped Celery
3T. Sugar                                            2 Chopped Green Onion
1 Head Romaine Lettuce                     1 (11oz) Can of Mandarins
2-3 Grilled Chicken Breasts                 Chow Mein Noodles

In a small pan cook almonds and sugar over medium heat. Stir until almonds are coated and sugar is dissolved. I marinate the chicken breasts in a soy sauce and hoisin sauce mixture, then grilled on a George Foreman Grill. Combine lettuce, chicken, celery and onion. Add dressing and mandarins just before serving. I serve almonds and chow mein noodles on the side.

Dressing:
1/4c. Olive Oil                                    2T. Balsamic Vinegar
2 T. Sugar                                          1T. Chopped Parsley
2-3T. Juice from Mandarins                Salt and Pepper


Dump Cake
1 can Crushed Pinapple                         1 can Cherry Pie Filling
1 stick of Butter (melted)                       1 White or Yellow Cake Mix

Dump un-drained pineapple in a 9x13 baking pan, spread it out across the bottom of the pan. Glob the cherry  pie filling onto the pineapple. Sprinkle the cake mix over the top (sometimes I add chopped nuts). Pour melted butter over the top. Bake for about an hour at 350 degrees. Serve like cobbler with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream!

Saturday, January 19, 2013

Who says you can't meet great people in a bar?

About a year ago, that's exactly how I met Christine and Andrea... and incredible meals, fantastic wine and wonderful times have followed. We were three strangers that happened to attend the same cheese & spice pairing, held at a local bar. We got to chatting and realized we all live within a few miles of each other so we hatched a plan: one of us would host dinner, another would bring the wine, and the third would kick back and relax. The next week, we'd rotate.

Four days after we met, our modest little wine club had its first get together. We now have one road trip, countless (free!) wine tastings, one Bruce Springsteen concert, one new car, four revisions to our wine rating score card, one career move, one new apartment and 83 bottles of wine under our belts. I have learned that Andrea is absolutely fearless in the kitchen, Christine can saber a bottle of champagne and me... well, I have learned that unless I have a picture, I can't remember what I had to eat with that bottle of wine!

So here is a log of our explorations and adventures, a record of our journey to expand our horizons and learn from each other. Feel free to take a peek.

Welcome to The Vine Diary and thanks for stopping by.